Posner speaking at the Federalist Society of Harvard Law School in 2017. Photo from Wikipedia

by George Taniwaki

Richard Allen Posner, one of the pioneers in the field of the law and economics movement, has died. He was 87. Back in the early 1980s, when I was getting my MBA at the University of Chicago, the idea that microeconomic theory could be used to analyze all types of social issues, like marriage, crime, discrimination, kidney donation, and political influence was transitioning from being a fringe idea to becoming a mainstream theory. And the two leading scholars in the field were Richard Posner and Gary Becker, who both taught at U of C. Prof Becker taught at the school of economics and Prof Posner at the school of law.

Mr. Posner was appointed to be on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit by Ronald Reagan and had an enormous impact on legal thinking. He has been called the most cited American legal scholar of all time. A complete obituary is available at University of Chicago Law School.

* * * *

[Update: Added kidney donation to the list of issues that law and economics can help explain.]

The Turner family benefited from New York’s landmark Living Donor Support Program. Photos courtesy of Amy Turner

by George Taniwaki

Today, Sam Mellins reports (New York Focus, Nov 2026) on a family that benefited from New York state’s Living Donor Support Program. This success comes after years of lack of action by the state as reported in a blog post from over a year ago (Real Numeracy, Apr 2025) based on previous reporting by Sam Mellins (New York Focus, Apr 2025).

How New York’s first-of-its-kind organ donation program helped a family stay afloat

Amy Turner donated a kidney to her husband Zamar. A new state program to reimburse organ donors helped them avoid a debt spiral.

Upstate New Yorkers Amy and Zamar Turner have worked hard to achieve financial stability for themselves, their three kids, and their five English mastiffs.

After Zamar retired from two decades of military service in 2017, he started a medical transportation business. Amy got a master’s degree and began working as a therapist. They bought a house in 2021, in Dexter, New York, a few miles from the Canadian border, and moved out of the military housing they had been renting in nearby Fort Drum.

But when Zamar’s chronic kidney issues turned into full-blown organ failure, the crisis threatened to undo all their effort. He had to give up his business, and Amy cut back her therapy hours to care for him. They fell thousands of dollars behind on phone and electric bills, and had to refinance their mortgage at a steeper rate.

Amy qualified as a kidney donor for her ailing husband, but the costs associated with the operation and her recovery time threatened to push the family thousands of dollars further into debt.

In the past, there would have been no alternative. But several years ago, state lawmakers passed legislation to reimburse organ donors’ medical and recovery costs. In a state with one of the longest waitlists for donation, they hoped to make it possible for more families, friends and strangers to volunteer.  After the law passed in 2022, however, it faced years of bureaucratic delays, detailed by New York Focus.

No longer. The Living Donor Support Program launched last year, and has already approved over 240 applications — more than twice the number health department officials were expecting.

The Turner family is one of them. The program covered Amy’s missed paychecks, travel expenses to and from the hospital in Rochester, and the cost of having Amy’s sister come from Maine to help care for them during recovery.

“It helped a lot,” Amy said. “It filled the gap on not having our electric turned off.”

The program allows organ donors to claim up to $14,000 in reimbursements from the state to cover costs like lost wages, travel, and caretakers.

In its first year, the program paid out more than $714,000 in reimbursements, according to a health department spokesperson.

Program staff were only expecting 100 applications in the first year, so getting more than twice that number kept them very busy, said health department employee Loretta Mosher, one of three staffers devoted full-time to the Living Donor Support Program.

Mosher joined the department of health in 2024 specifically to help launch the program. She had spent the previous 20 years as a hospital nurse, sometimes witnessing organ donation up close.

“Working in the emergency room, you see a lot of people who are donors,” she told New York Focus. “You just gain a really deep respect for it.”

Now, she spends all day corresponding with donors and the 15 transplant centers that coordinate the procedures around New York state. Mosher and her colleagues try to respond to all applications and reimbursement claims within a day.

Donors and their families seem to appreciate the work. “Probably weekly, there’s emails back to us thanking us,” she said. Mosher and her team hope to grow the program by 10 percent per year.

At least one New Yorker has expressed his appreciation directly to Governor Kathy Hochul, who signed the program into law in late 2022.

During Hochul’s recent visit to a kosher supermarket in Queens, a man who said he had donated his kidney to a stranger thanked her for signing the bill.

“I got to give my kidney to someone I don’t know. You gave me this check,” the man said while holding up a check, according to jns.org. “You’re the only governor who has a law like that.”

While other countries such as New Zealand and Israel have similar programs, which have been found to boost donation rates, New York is the only state that reimburses organ donors.

Kidney issues had dogged Zamar for years before the organ totally failed. Several years before he retired from the military — where he served in Iraq, Korea, and Okinawa — he found out he had diseased and low-functioning kidneys, but he shrugged it off

“That’s the mentality you develop when you’re in the military,” he said. “Someone tells you you’re sick, you’re kind of like okay, whatever.”

But last year, chronic vomiting and back pain forced him back to the hospital, where he learned his kidneys were failing, and that he would need to start dialysis. It was a brutal process: He would get crippling cramps, often couldn’t sleep for more than a few minutes at a time, and at one point needed surgery to remove an infected catheter.

While Zamar was on dialysis, Amy was undergoing testing to see if she could be his kidney donor. After several rounds, she learned in April that she was a match. They set the surgery date for July, after their son Devon’s high school graduation.

As they prepared for the transplant, a member of the hospital’s staff told Amy about the Living Donor Support Program, and suggested that she apply. Initially Amy wasn’t interested — it just seemed like one more bureaucratic task to deal with. But as the transplant date approached, their financial struggles mounted. When a hospital employee mentioned the program again, she decided to apply and was approved right away.

Two weeks after she began submitting claims, she started getting reimbursement checks in the mail. A Department of Health staff member quickly responded to any questions that came up.

“It was a lot easier than I thought it was going to be,” Amy said. “It’s just really a couple pieces of paper.”

The roughly $3,000 the Turners ultimately received from the program was far less than the $14,000 cap, but it was enough to make a real dent in the bills that had piled up while Zamar was sick.

“The smoke has cleared up,” Amy said. “We’ll get there eventually.”

Zamar is still recovering from the transplant surgery, but he can already feel the difference. He’s started doing a bit of yard work again, and recently went out to lunch with his family for the first time in about a year. Most importantly, he’s able to stay awake rather than sleeping for half the day, as he often would when he was on dialysis.

“I used to have raccoon eyes,” he said. “I don’t have those no more.”

Let’s allow a fair trade in kidneys. Video from YouTube

by Frank McCormick 
Subscribe to Frank’s newsletter

Friends, Frederike Ambagtsheer is an assistant professor at the Erasmus MC Dept. of Internal Medicine. She gave this excellent TEDx talk in 2017 entitled, “Let’s allow a fair trade in kidneys”.

Every year, thousands of patients die because an organ could not be found in time to save their life. The organ crisis does not only lead to patient deaths; it has also fueled a global illegal organ market with great ethical, legal and medical risks for both patients and donors. The prohibition of organ trade has increased the value and profitability of organs, and has driven the trade underground, leading to high victimization rates. Patients’ deaths and black market abuses can be prevented if we legalize the trade in organs, through a government-controlled regulated organ market. In this talk, Let’s allow a fair trade in kidneys, Frederike argues that fair trade in organs is achievable, by taking one step beyond and changing our ideas and beliefs about the organ trade.


Frederike Ambagtsheer is the initiator and coordinator of the HOTT project. She studied Criminology and Public International Law and finished her PhD on organ trade cum laude in 2017. Until 2014 she was the coordinator of the European Platform on Ethical, Legal and Psychosocial aspects of Transplantation (ELPAT). In addition, she has worked for the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime in the department of human trafficking for organ removal. From September 2017 until February 2018, she will continue her research as a visiting scholar at the School of Criminology and Criminal Justice at Northeastern University in Boston (USA).

This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at https://www.ted.com/tedx

Photo from Wall St. J.

by Frank McCormick 
Subscribe to Frank’s newsletter

Elaine Perlman calls our attention to this excellent article by our dear friend Sally Satel published today in support of the End Kidney Deaths Act (Wall St J, Nov 2026) subscription required and reproduced below.

Organ donation needs an overhaul

Every year, thousands of people die waiting for an organ donor. Passing the End Kidney Deaths Act would help save lives.

I joined a dubious fraternity 20 years ago: People unfortunate enough to need a new organ, but lucky enough to get one.

Those who are blessed with a living donor—in my case, a wonderful friend—represent about 1 in 3 kidney recipients. The others are beneficiaries of the national waiting list.

That list is run by the United Network for Organ Sharing, enabled by the National Organ Transplant Act of 1984. UNOS procures hearts, livers, lungs and kidneys from the newly deceased and allocates them. Before UNOS, states tried their best to collect and distribute organs independently. On several occasions, President Reagan even flew children on Air Force One to hospitals ready to give them new livers.

UNOS has since streamlined organ donation. Still, there have never been enough organs to meet demand. In 2006 I was one of about 16,000 patients to get a kidney. About 70,000 others waited for their names to crawl to the top of the list. Roughly 12 patients died each day—as they do today, unable to survive the wait.

In fact, a new report from the Health and Human Services Department states that the life expectancy of people on dialysis hasn’t changed since 2009. Then and now, patients have a five-year survival probability of less than 50%. Those who live still face the immense financial burden of Medicare dialysis, which costs more than $110,000 a patient each year.

There is a reasonable step we can take to save lives and cut costs. The National Organ Transplant Act currently forbids life-saving living donors to receive any material reward for their sacrifice. This needs to change.

The current donation process requires desperate patients to rely solely on uncompensated altruism, which is a beautiful sentiment. It worked for me in 2006 and again in 2016 when I unexpectedly needed a second transplant and was rescued by another magnificent friend. But it isn’t the basis for a viable policy. Although 49% of Americans say they’re at least somewhat likely to give a kidney to a stranger, very few actually do.

This is why I, along with a committed group of nephrologists, transplant surgeons, economists, organ donors and organ recipients, have been working with lawmakers to legalize meaningful rewards for people willing to save the life of another.

The End Kidney Deaths Act, introduced in 2023 by Rep. Nicole Malliotakis, a Republican from New York and Rep. Josh Harder, a Democrat from California, would provide a $50,000 refundable tax credit to any living donor who gives a kidney to a stranger. The bill calls for a 10-year pilot program, with credit applying to kidney donations made in 2027 through 2036. It has been referred to committee and, in the meantime, it gains more co-sponsors at each House session.

The purpose of the tax benefit is to galvanize into action the humane impulses of millions of people who have already considered donating to a stranger. It may also incentivize those who haven’t.

To be clear, it would still be illegal to buy organs. All transplants would proceed, as they do now, through medical centers. Donors would continue to be protected by informed-consent requirements. Because the standard medical and psychological screenings for would-be donors take many months to complete and the tax credit would be disbursed over a five-year period, the credit wouldn’t attract those seeking a quick cash grab.

Lawfully-compensated donors will be no less heroic for being materially enriched, and they will experience one of the most moving and gratifying acts of a lifetime.

The idea of reciprocation isn’t new. When Rep. Al Gore spoke at a 1983 congressional hearing for the National Organ Transplant Act, he said “a voucher system or a tax credit to a donor’s estate” should be considered if “efforts to improve voluntary donation are unsuccessful.” Well, voluntary donation numbers have stagnated. It’s time for innovation.

I have been lucky beyond reason. Too many others with failing kidneys don’t have family or friends willing or able to donate, leaving them at the cold mercy of medical rationing. This is a fate that Congress could spare them. Bad luck shouldn’t be a death sentence.


Dr. Satel is a psychiatrist, a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and a lecturer at Yale University School of Medicine.

Getting my endangered alphabets carvings to where they are needed. Photo from Tim Brookes

by George Taniwaki

Last year, Tim Brookes, the founder of the Atlas of Endangered Alphabets launched a Kickstarter campaign to send his calligraphic carvings to the people who could benefit from acknowledgement that their spoken and written languages are worth saving. He finished all the carvings in August. You can read about it here.

Now he has a new Kickstarter campaign to fund the launch of his new book, Liquid.

* * * *

Separately, Tim published a book last year, entitled By Hand. Learn more about the book at the By Hand website; links to buy the book at the bottom of the page. A good review is at MultiLingual (Oct 2025).

I have previously highlighted Tim’s work on preserving rare languages at Real Numeracy (Aug 2011).

You wouldn’t strap a string trimmer to a dog to do yard work, or would you. Image generated by Microsoft Copilot

by George Taniwaki

Rachel Morris has a succinct article about corporate liability in the age of AI (Slate, Oct 2026). In it, she argues that the criminal justice system is not prepared to charge companies with negligence if their AI agents cause harm because it is unlikely that evidence of intent will be found. Instead, she says civil suits may be the only action available to those harmed. Near the end of the article is this gem.

[C]omputer scientist Cal Newport likened OpenAI’s training approach to strapping a Weedwacker to your dog to do yard work. If the dog jumped the fence and dinged the neighbors’ cars, “you wouldn’t shake your head and lament about how the dog/whacker system had ‘gone rogue’ ” he observed. “You would instead concede that dogs are unpredictable, so it was dumb to attach something dangerous to one.”

Naturally, upon reading that, I had to use AI to create an image to that illustrates this canine fantasy (see image at top of this entry). Enjoy.

Side comment

Hopefully, no dogs, cars, or lawn tools were harmed by the creation of my image.

Nostalgia

Way back in my market research days, I did brand research on string trimmers. Back then machine learning models were too expensive to run, so all of our analysis was done using cross-tabs between categories (by brand names, by gas vs electric, by price range, by length of ownership, by frequency of use, etc.). We used z-statistic and chi-squared-statistic for significance.

Copy this image and paste it on your representative’s social media platform. Image from endkidneydeathsact.org

by George Taniwaki

If you are a supporter of the End Kidney Deaths Act (EKDA, HR 2687), and you should be, then Elaine Perlman, executive director of Waitlist Zero says you can show your support by taking the following two actions.

1. Sign the petition

It is easy to show Congress your support for a bill that will help save lives, improve medical outcomes, and reduce Medicare expenses. All it takes is your name.

  1. Go to Petition to Support the EKDA and fill out the form
  2. Share the link with your community and ask them to sign it too

2. Ask your congressional candidates if they support the EKDA

With the November elections approaching, we’re asking congressional candidates one simple question: “Do you support passing the End Kidney Deaths Act to help end the kidney shortage?”

Here’s how to participate:

  1. 🔎 CHECK FIRST! See whether your current House representative is already an EKDA cosponsor
  2. 📲 POST our Take the Pledge graphic (copy it from the top of this post) on the social media pages of congressional candidates in your district who haven’t already endorsed the bill
  3. 📣 TAG the candidates and ask them to state their position publicly
  4. ✅ REQUEST A RESPONSE: YES or NOT YET
  5. 📩 SHARE their responses with our campaign!

🏛️ Please remember to ask your two U.S. Senators and your House Representative to state their positions on EKDA.

Voters deserve to know where congressional candidates stand on legislation that will save thousands of American lives and billions in taxpayer dollars! 🇺🇸